TEXT

Risālah dar ʿilm-i hayʾat [P] (al-Qūshjī)

Title (arabic)

رساله در علم هيئت

Title (translit)

Risālah dar ʿilm-i hayʾat (al-Qūshjī) [P]

Alias

فارسى هيئت
Risālah dar falakiyyāt
Risālah-yi fārisiyyah dar hayʾat
Risālah fī al-hayʾah
رسالة في علم الهيئة
رساله در هيئت لعلى قوشجى

Author

Created

862H/1457J

Created in

Language

Persian-Farsi

Subject

Text type

First-order prose composition (or compilation) [matn]

Other versions

Translated in

Commented in

Notes

Qūshjī’s Risālah dar ʿilm-i hayʾat was written in Persian and completed in Samarqand circa 862/1458 prior to his other astronomical composition (in Arabic) al-Fatḥiyya, which Qūshjī completed shortly before his death. The Risālah was widely read and studied, as indicated by: the number of extant manuscript copies of the work (some 100); the work was translated into Arabic, Turkish, Sanskrit, Judeo-Persian, and Latin; the Risālah was studied in madrasas (in Ottoman lands, India, and Iran); and Muṣliḥ al-Dīn al-Lārī (d. 979/1572)’s Risālah commentary on it was also widely circulated.

Although one manuscript has a later dedication to Bāyazīd II, no manuscript examined so far has a dedication corresponding to the date of composition, so the historical context of its composition remains unclear. Nonetheless, the treatise possesses some unique features that make it significant both for understanding Qūshjī’s career and for studying the hayʾa tradition. First, the section typically found in many hayʾa works on the natural philosophical principles of astronomy is absent in Qūshjī’s other hayʾa text, al-Risāla al-fatḥiyya, but it is present in Risālah dar ʿilm-i hayʾat. Second, although Ptolemaic astronomical issues are not discussed in great detail, several are briefly mentioned throughout the text. Third, in several instances, Qūshjī references the results of the Samarqand observatory. Finally, there are at least 2 versions: it appears that the work originally lacked a section on planetary sizes and distances (Version 1), but this was added later by Qūshjī himself at the end of the text (Version 2), usually in the added 12th chapter of Part 2 or as a separate part.

ismi_id

42839

Manuscript Witnesses

29 witnesses:

Literature References

Umut, Hasan. 2019. “Theoretical Astronomy in the Early Modern Ottoman Empire: ʿAlī Al-Qūshjī’s Al-Risāla Al-Fatḥiyya”. Institute of Islamic Studies. Montreal, Quebec: McGill University.
Uymaz, Tuba. 2009. “Seydî Ali Reis’in Hülâsa El-Heyʾe (Astronominin Özeti) Adlı Eseri Üzerine Bir İnceleme”. University of Ankara.
De Young, Gregg. 2004. “John Greaves’ Astronomica Quaedam: Orientalism and Ptolemaic Cosmography in Seventeenth Century England”. Indian Journal of History of Science 39 (4): 467-510.
Birışık, Abdülhamit. 2003. “Hint Alt Kıtasında Medrese”. In TDV İslam Ansiklopedisi, 28:333-38. Ankara: TDV Yayınları.
Rozenfeld, Boris, and Ekmeleddin İhsanoğlu. 2003. Mathematicians, Astronomers and Other Scholars of Islamic Civilisation and Their Works (7th-19th c.). Istanbul: Research Centre for Islamic History, Art, and Culture.

Pp. 286-87 (no. 845), A1.

İhsanoğlu, Ekmeleddin. 1997. Osmanlı Astronomi Literatürü Tarihi [History of Astronomy Literature During the Ottoman Period]. Osmanlı Bilim Tarihi literatürü. Istanbul: İslâm Tarih, Sanat ve Kültür Araştırma Merkezi (IRCICA).

Vol. 1, pp. 30-33 (no. 11), 2.

al-Lārī Muṣliḥ al-Dīn. 1971. Kommentariĭ K Astronomicheskomu Traktatu “Risala Dar falakiiat” Ali Kushchi (Posobiye Dlya Studentov). Trans. A. U. Usmanova. Samarqand: N/A.
al-Qūshjī ʿAlāʾ al-Dīn ʿAlī b. Muḥammad. 1970. Astronomicheskiy Traktat (Posobiye Dlya Studentov). Trans. A. U. Usmanova. Samarqand: N/A.
Muminov, I. 1968. Astronomiya Oid Risola. Tashkent: N/A.
Adıvar, Abdülhak Adnan. 1943. Osmanlı Türklerinde İlim. Istanbul: Maarif Matbaası.

P. 81.

Khalifa, Hajji. 1835. Hajji Khalifa. Kashf Al-ẓunūn ʿan asāmī Al-Kutub waʾl-funūn = Lexicon Bibliographicum Et Encyclopaedicum a Mustafa Ben Abdallah Katib Jelebi Dicto Et Nomine Haji Khalfa Celebrato Compositum. Ed. Gustav Flügel. 7 vol. Leipzig-London: R. Bentley for the Oriental Translation Fund of Great Britain and Ireland.

Vol. 3, p. 458.

Gravii, Johannis. 1652. Astronomica Quaedam Ex Traditione Shah Cholgii Persae: Una Cum Hypothesibus Planetarum. London: N/A.